Imagine pushing a young superstar to the absolute limit, only to watch their performance dip – and then wondering if it was all worth it. That's the heart-wrenching realization hitting Reds manager Terry Francona as he reflects on handling Elly De La Cruz's playing time during the 2025 season. But here's where it gets controversial: is forcing rest on a determined athlete the right call, or does it undermine the very grit that makes baseball heroes? Stick around, because this tale of energy, endurance, and tough decisions might change how you view player management in the game.
In the sunny city of Orlando, Florida, during the Winter Meetings, Francona openly admitted that with the clarity of hindsight, he would approach things differently when it came to deciding how much All-Star shortstop Elly De La Cruz (https://www.mlb.com/player/elly-de-la-cruz-682829) got to play ball. For beginners in baseball stats, think of De La Cruz as a high-energy dynamo whose speed and power make him a fan favorite – kind of like a turbocharged version of a classic shortstop.
Throughout that packed 2025 campaign, De La Cruz suited up for every single one of the 162 regular-season games, starting in 161 of them, and even added two more in the postseason. Yet, as the season wore on into the second half, his offensive punch noticeably faded while he battled a persistent strain in his left quadriceps muscle (https://www.mlb.com/reds/news/elly-de-la-cruz-played-with-quad-injury-for-part-of-2025-season). To break that down simply: injuries like this can slow players down, making it harder to run bases, swing with full force, or even just move comfortably on the field. It's a common issue in a sport where athletes push their bodies daily, and for newcomers, imagine trying to perform a marathon every day despite a nagging ache – that's the kind of toll it takes.
"A bunch of factors were at play," Francona shared on Monday amid the Winter Meetings buzz. "I believe I need to own this – and I do, fully. I should have figured out better ways to give him some downtime off his feet, and I fell short there, so that's on me." For context, the Winter Meetings are like a big annual gathering where teams trade players, sign deals, and plan for the future, sponsored by CohnReznick for complete coverage (https://www.mlb.com/news/topic/winter-meetings-coverage).
Adding to the emotional weight, the 23-year-old De La Cruz – who's celebrating his 24th birthday on January 11 – didn't skip a single game, not even after the heartbreaking loss of his sister on May 31 (https://www.mlb.com/reds/news/elly-de-la-cruz-honors-sister-s-death-with-home-run-vs-cubs). In fact, he resisted sitting out when Francona tried using him as the designated hitter in four contests, a role where batters don't play defense to save wear and tear.
Francona appreciates De La Cruz's passion, saying, "I absolutely admire his desire to be out there, and he's one of those unique talents who brings infectious energy to every single game, which is truly remarkable." But he added a note of caution: "That said, he takes a real beating on the field. Sometimes, a day off after a night game could really recharge his batteries."
If you're shopping for Reds fans this holiday season, check out some great gift ideas at the MLB Shop (https://www.mlbshop.com/holiday-gift-guide/t-3082+c-9904?_s=bm-mlb.com-Banner-2025-MLB.com-Web-Banner-cin) – perfect for showing support to the team.
De La Cruz wrapped up the year with solid numbers: a .264 batting average, a .776 OPS (that's on-base plus slugging percentage, a key stat combining hits, walks, and power – higher is better, like scoring more points in a game), 22 home runs, 86 runs batted in, and 37 stolen bases. This helped the Reds snag a postseason spot as the third National League Wild Card team (https://www.mlb.com/reds/news/reds-clinch-2025-playoff-berth).
Yet, the slump was telling: after smashing 18 homers in his first 79 games and 302 at-bats, he managed just four more in the remaining 83 games and 327 at-bats. It was like watching a sprinter hit a wall mid-race – his power output dwindled, likely tied to that quad issue and sheer fatigue.
Looking ahead to 2026, Francona hasn't set a hard number on how many games De La Cruz should play. "I don't see a magic figure," he explained. "But I also realize that waiting until it's too late, as I did last season, means the help comes too little, too late. A single day off in September probably won't cut it. We need to act ahead of time, and I owe it to him to communicate this clearly so he grasps the why behind it. ... Bottom line, I have to step up my game in managing this, and I intend to."
And this is the part most people miss – the bigger picture for the Reds as a whole. Francona aims to improve on their 83-79 record from his inaugural year at the helm in Cincinnati, where they got swept in two games by the Dodgers in the NL Wild Card Series (https://www.mlb.com/reds/news/reds-eliminated-by-dodgers-in-nl-wild-card-series-2025). "Our aim isn't just to hit 83 wins," he stated. "As long as we're trending upward, securing playoff berths is the prize. I don't want us to become that 'cute little underdog story' that fizzles out afterward. We've all savored the thrill of popping champagne in victory, but just days later, we felt the sharp pain of a quick exit. I remind the team to hold onto both memories – the highs and the lows – to fuel our drive."
For a deeper dive, consider this controversial angle: While Francona's push for rest makes sense from a health perspective – preventing burnout and injuries that could sideline a player long-term – does it clash with the old-school baseball ethic of playing through pain? De La Cruz's refusal to sit out, even amid personal tragedy, paints him as a warrior, but at what cost to his career? Is a manager's job to protect players from themselves, or to let their passion shine, even if it risks overexertion? And here's a thought-provoking question: Do you think Francona is right to intervene, or should stars like De La Cruz have the final say on their playing time? Share your take in the comments – agree, disagree, or add your own twist. What do you believe is the best balance between determination and caution in sports?
