Could the mysterious Can of Worms on The Masked Singer actually be a household name? Fans are buzzing with excitement, convinced they’ve unmasked the celebrity behind the costume—and it’s none other than TV and music sensation Marvin Humes. But here’s where it gets controversial: while many are certain, others are pointing fingers at his JLS bandmate JB Gill or even other stars like Reggie Yates and Olly Murs. Let’s dive into the clues that have everyone talking.
Since its debut on ITV, the Can of Worms character has sparked endless speculation. But ahead of the January 24 episode, one theory has taken the internet by storm. Eagle-eyed viewers have pieced together eight distinct clues that seemingly point directly to Marvin Humes, the former X Factor star and husband of This Morning’s Rochelle Humes. This theory gained traction on Reddit, where fans meticulously analyzed every hint, from subtle references to Marvin’s parenting techniques to nods to his morning TV appearances.
One of the most talked-about clues? A videotape featuring a yellow step in a garden labeled the “naughty step.” Fans quickly connected this to Marvin’s interviews about using this parenting method with his children, a topic he and Rochelle have discussed on This Morning. And this is the part most people miss: the “early bird” references and bakery visuals could tie into Marvin’s frequent morning TV gigs, where breakfast recipes are a staple.
But it doesn’t stop there. The phrase “written in the stars” has raised eyebrows, given JLS’s collaboration with Tinie Tempah on Eyes Wide Shut and Tinie’s hit single by the same name. Then there’s the appearance of Top Gear stars James May and Richard Hammond, whose initials (MH) match Marvin’s. Is this a classic Masked Singer initials clue, or just a coincidence?
Gardening references have also played a big role in the theory. A can of worms surrounded by greenery could nod to the color green, which fans associate with Marvin’s branding and early JLS merchandise. Even a courgette at a public event has been interpreted as a subtle reference to Marvin hosting the 2016 BAFTA Children’s Awards, the same year My Life as a Courgette won Best Animated Feature. Talk about connecting the dots!
The final clue that sealed the deal for many? A line about something “running in the family.” Fans believe this could refer to Marvin’s close bond with his JLS bandmates, whom he often calls his brothers. Last week, social media erupted with similar guesses, with viewers flooding X (formerly Twitter) with comments like, “Is Marvin from JLS the Can of Worms?!!” and “I swear I just heard Marvin Humes’ voice.”
However, not everyone is convinced. Some fans argue that the clues could point to JB Gill, while others suggest names like Reggie Yates, Olly Murs, or Mark Owen. So, who’s behind the mask? Is it Marvin, JB, or someone else entirely? Let us know your thoughts in the comments—this debate is far from over!
